| U. E. Red Simonton | 1960 | Tom Simmons | 1992 |
| Hayes G. Stewart | 1961 | Tom Simmons | 1993 |
| Glenn O. Gross | 1962 | Tom Simmons | 1994 |
| Lynton G. Bauer | 1963 | Tom Simmons | 1995 |
| Alex L. Duncan | 1964 | Tom Simmons | 1996 |
| Neil Smith | 1965 | Tom Simmons | 1997 |
| Virgil Harden | 1966 | Pete E Cons Jr | 1998 |
| Dick Andersen | 1967 | Gene Sodders | 1999 |
| Sam Quinn | 1968 | Tom Simmons | 2000 |
| Bob McDaniel | 1969 | Mike Clemensen | 2001 |
| Hart Avery | 1970 | Betty Patton | 2002 |
| John Wesson | 1971 | Patty Ham | 2003 |
| Ed Ross | 1972 | Ben Heller | 2004 |
| Don Lee | 1973 | Tom Simmons | 2005 |
| Jim Fullmer | 1974 | Betty Patton | 2006 |
| Kenny Kisner | 1975 | Art Dinges | 2007 |
| Bill Anderson | 1976 | Art Dinges | 2008 |
| Lonnie Wells | 1977 | Tom Simmons | 2009 |
| Alex Duncan | 1978 | Tom Simmons | 2010 |
| Carl Youtzy | 1979 | Hans Groot | 2011 |
| Fred Bear | 1980 | Hans Groot | 2012 |
| Don Shapiro | 1981 | Tom Simmons | 2013 |
| Don Hedden | 1982 | Tom Simmons | 2014 |
| Bill Gardner | 1983 | Hans Groot | 2015 |
| Bill Anderson | 1984 | Tom Simmons | 2016 |
| Ken Kisner | 1985 | Hans Groot | 2017 |
| Don Lee | 1986 | Tom Simmons | 2018 |
| Bill Spence | 1987 | Hans Groot | 2019 |
| John Lawritson | 1988 | Richard Liebhaber | 2020 |
| Gary Siegalkoff | 1989 | Eddie Richardson | 2021 |
| Mike Miller | 1990 | Allen Fogel | 2022 |
| Gary Wilson | 1991 | Eddie Richardson |
2023 |
